Previous
Two-Factor Codes & RNG
All Articles
Next
Randomness in Cryptography
SecurityMarch 15, 20259 min read

Password Strength Checkers: How Accurate Are They?

G
GensGPT Team
Security Analysis Experts

Those green bars and "strong password" messages might be giving you false confidence. Let's analyze popular password strength meters, uncover their limitations, and learn what truly makes a secure password in 2025.

The Password Checker Problem

Many password strength checkers use outdated criteria that don't reflect modern attack methods. They often give high scores to passwords that are easily cracked by today's tools, creating a dangerous false sense of security.

Key Issue: A password rated "Very Strong" by popular checkers can often be cracked in minutes by specialized software.

Popular Password Checkers Analyzed

HaveIBeenPwned Password Checker

Breach DatabaseVery High Accuracy

"Checks if password has been compromised in data breaches"

✅ Strengths

  • • Checks actual breaches
  • • Privacy-focused
  • • Regularly updated
  • • Trusted source

❌ Limitations

  • • Only checks breaches, not strength
  • • Limited real-time feedback

Bitwarden Password Strength Meter

Built-in ToolHigh Accuracy

"Integrated password manager strength assessment"

✅ Strengths

  • • Good entropy calculation
  • • Real-time feedback
  • • Considers patterns

❌ Limitations

  • • Simple visual indicator
  • • Not detailed breakdown

Microsoft Password Strength Meter

Basic CheckerMedium Accuracy

"Basic length and character type checking"

✅ Strengths

  • • Simple interface
  • • Quick feedback
  • • Common patterns detection

❌ Limitations

  • • Overly simplistic
  • • Misleading results
  • • Limited criteria

Kaspersky Password Checker

Security VendorHigh Accuracy

"Comprehensive security analysis with time estimates"

✅ Strengths

  • • Good algorithm
  • • Time to crack estimates
  • • Pattern recognition

❌ Limitations

  • • Overly optimistic sometimes
  • • Proprietary algorithm

Common Checker Mistakes

Overemphasis on Character Types

What checkers do: Many checkers require uppercase, lowercase, numbers, and symbols
The problem: P@ssw0rd1 scores high but is predictable and weak
The reality: Length and unpredictability matter more than character diversity

Ignoring Dictionary Attacks

What checkers do: Checkers miss that password uses common words
The problem: MyDog2023! seems strong but uses predictable patterns
The reality: Dictionary words make passwords vulnerable regardless of modifications

False Sense of Security

What checkers do: Green bars make users think their password is safe
The problem: Users stop improving passwords after reaching "strong"
The reality: Many "strong" passwords are easily cracked by modern tools

No Breach Database Check

What checkers do: Not checking if password has been compromised before
The problem: Strong-looking password might already be in attacker databases
The reality: Previously breached passwords should never be used

Better Ways to Measure Password Strength

Entropy

Measure of randomness and unpredictability

How it's calculated: log2(possible_characters^password_length)
Good value: 50+ bits for personal use, 70+ for sensitive accounts

Time to Crack

Estimated time for brute force attack

How it's calculated: Based on entropy and current computing power
Good value: 1000+ years at current GPU speeds

Pattern Analysis

Detection of common substitutions and patterns

How it's calculated: Check against known patterns and transformations
Good value: No detectable patterns or common substitutions

Compromise Status

Whether password appears in known breaches

How it's calculated: Check against databases like HaveIBeenPwned
Good value: Never appeared in any known data breach

Real Password Examples: Checker vs Reality

Password
P@ssw0rd123
Checker Says
Strong
Reality
Very Weak
Crack Time
Minutes
Why
Common pattern with predictable substitutions
Password
MyDogFluffy2023!
Checker Says
Very Strong
Reality
Weak
Crack Time
Hours to days
Why
Personal information + year + exclamation
Password
correct-horse-battery-staple
Checker Says
Medium
Reality
Strong
Crack Time
Thousands of years
Why
High entropy through length and word combination
Password
Tr0ub4dor&3
Checker Says
Strong
Reality
Medium
Crack Time
Days to weeks
Why
Known pattern from XKCD comic
Password
J7x9$mN2kP8vQ5#wR1zY
Checker Says
Very Strong
Reality
Very Strong
Crack Time
Millions of years
Why
High entropy, random characters, good length

How to Really Evaluate Password Security

✅ Step-by-Step Security Check

1
Check for Breaches
Use HaveIBeenPwned to verify the password hasn't been compromised
2
Calculate True Entropy
Consider actual randomness, not just character types
3
Look for Patterns
Check for dictionary words, personal info, and predictable patterns
4
Estimate Crack Time
Use realistic attack models based on current technology

Modern Password Recommendations

What Actually Works

  • • Length over complexity: 4 random words beat complex 8-character passwords
  • • True randomness: Use password generators for critical accounts
  • • Unique per site: Never reuse passwords across services
  • • Password managers: Let software handle the complexity
  • • Regular updates: Change passwords when sites are breached

What Doesn't Work

  • • Common substitutions: @ for a, 3 for e, etc.
  • • Personal information: Names, birthdays, addresses
  • • Dictionary words: Even with numbers and symbols
  • • Keyboard patterns: qwerty123, asdf1234
  • • Short complexity: P@ssw0rd1 is still weak

The Bottom Line

Most password strength checkers are using outdated methods that don't reflect modern attack techniques. Don't trust the green bars - instead, focus on using unique, randomly generated passwords for each account, preferably managed by a reputable password manager.

The most secure password is one you can't remember - because it's stored securely in a password manager and generated randomly for each service you use.

Related Articles

How to Create Secure Passwords in 2025

Complete guide to modern password security practices.

Avoiding Predictable Passwords

Common password mistakes and how to avoid them.

Generate Truly Secure Passwords

Stop relying on misleading strength meters. Create cryptographically secure passwords!

Generate Password